The comparison · Mailstinger vs. EasyDMARC

EasyDMARC is the dashboard. Mailstinger is the fix.

EasyDMARC will happily show you that 40% of your mail is misaligned. Then you close the tab and stare at your DNS zone. We write the TXT for you.

EasyDMARC pricing
$39.99/mo starter (1 domain). Paid plans scale per-domain; MSP tier starts around $89/mo for 10 client accounts.
See their pricing page →
Mailstinger pricing
$49/mo for 5 domains (Business). $149/mo for 25 client domains (Agency). No per-domain ramp.
At 10 domains, we're $0.98/domain/month. They're ~$3.20/domain/month at equivalent volume.
Credit where it's due

Here's what EasyDMARC genuinely does well.

No false dichotomy. If these are deal-breakers for your context, they might be the right choice. We'd rather you buy the right tool than hate us in six months.

  • Clean, modern UI — better first-look aesthetics than dmarcian and most enterprise tools in the category.
  • Free tier with real data (rua ingest, up to one domain). Good for evaluation without a procurement conversation.
  • Solid threat-intel feeds on the Business+ tiers — they've built a legit reputation database for sender IPs.
§02 · Where we diverge

Capability by capability. Everything listed here is verifiable.

No hand-waving. If we claim a feature, it's shipped and you can test it free on the analyzer. If we claim a competitor doesn't have something, it's because their docs / pricing page / product tour say they don't.

Remediation vs. reporting
Mailstinger
Every misaligned sender row has a 'Paste-ready DNS fix' and on hosted-SPF one-click 'Authorise in SPF'.
EasyDMARC
Visualisation-first. Fixes surface as recommendations you implement elsewhere.
BEC / lookalike detection
Mailstinger
Included on Business. Daily typo-permutation sweep + WHOIS-freshness escalation + blocklist exports (M365 PS / GWS CSV).
EasyDMARC
Available as a separate 'Domain Scanner' bolt-on with its own pricing.
Tone-aware alerts (alert vs. bulk)
Mailstinger
Yes — transactional alerts strip List-Unsubscribe etc., which stops your 'your domain is being spoofed' email getting filtered as newsletter.
EasyDMARC
Standard alert pipeline. No tone split.
MSP multi-tenant isolation
Mailstinger
tenant_id first column of every table; row-level middleware enforcement.
EasyDMARC
MSP tier adds client hierarchy on top of a single-tenant schema.
Hosted SPF with auto-flatten
Mailstinger
Yes — past the 10-lookup cap, we auto-expand to ip4 ranges. Audit-logged.
EasyDMARC
Hosted SPF not a first-class feature; SPF flattening is a separate tool.
One-paste DMARC delegation
Mailstinger
CNAME once, we own every subsequent change on Agency tier.
EasyDMARC
They manage via API; delegation model is different.
The honest verdict

EasyDMARC is a better dashboard than dmarcian and most Proofpoint resellers. That's genuine credit. But if the job is to close the loop — detect, decide, publish the fix — you'll find yourself copying values into another tab. Mailstinger does the whole loop and costs less at the same domain count.

Also comparing